Jürgen Habermas'ta sivil itaatsizliğin meşruluğu
Thesis Type: Postgraduate
Institution Of The Thesis: Ankara University, Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, KAMU HUKUKU ANABİLİM DALI, Turkey
Approval Date: 2019
Thesis Language: Turkish
Student: ELİF CAN ÇALICI
Supervisor: GÜLRİZ UYGUR
Open Archive Collection: AVESIS Open Access Collection
Abstract:The concept of civil disobedience has been discussed as an instrument against the injustices in legal order that already exist or can arise, or the danger of corruption in legal order. This is based on the supposition that there is a fair legal order in general terms which is in need of additional control and reform mechanisms. On the subject of the legitimacy of civil disobedience, which is illegal by definition, Jürgen Habermas sets out from the hypothesis that modern constitutional governments need, and have the power for, moral affirmation. According to this, a democratic constitutional state should be based on the approval of its citizens, and cannot continue its existence without it. Acts of civil disobedience reflect the questioning of the legitimacy of democratic constitutional state. Through these acts, constitutional principles can be expressed and affirmed without being depended on positive law. The fact that legal norms may not be legitimate even in democratic constitutional states is an aspect that justifies civil disobedience. According to this perception, which accepts civil disobedience as an institution of democratic constitutional state, the state cannot base its legitimacy only on legality, and it also requires a moral basis. The concept of civil disobedience exactly functions as a way of testing that moral basis, thus it is "in between legality and legitimacy" according to the notion of Habermas.